It Is Not Always the Job: How to Tell Whether You Need a New Role or a New Employer

Posted on Tuesday, September 22, 2026 by Lydia Sinclair

It Is Not Always the Job: How to Tell Whether You Need a New Role or a New Employer

Posted 22 September 2026  ·  Lydia Sinclair

Woman sitting at a kitchen table with a closed laptop, looking out of the window

Most people in practice who tell me they want out have not yet worked out what they want out of.

Ask someone in practice why they are thinking of leaving and you tend to get one of two answers. “I need a new challenge.” Or, “I don’t think this is for me any more.”

Both are usually honest. Neither is usually accurate.

What sits underneath is a question almost nobody stops to answer properly, and it is the single most useful thing you can be clear on before you update your CV. Is the problem the work, or the place you are doing it?

The two expensive mistakes

 

There are only really two ways to get this wrong, and both are costly.

Mistake one

Blaming the profession when it is the employer

The more expensive of the two. People leave practice altogether, sometimes retraining, sometimes taking a significant pay cut to start again somewhere unrelated, when a different firm would have solved it within six months. Years of technical knowledge, client instinct and judgement, written off because of two bad managers.

Mistake two

Blaming the employer when it is the work

You move. The new place is better run, the people are nicer, and for a while you feel like you have fixed it. Around month four or five the flatness comes back, and this time it is worse, because you have run out of explanations.

Why a bad environment scrambles the signal

 

The reason this is hard is not a lack of self-awareness. It is that a poor environment contaminates everything it touches.

When you are being micromanaged, or blamed, or given unrealistic deadlines and no support, your brain does not carefully separate the spreadsheet from the person who shouted about the spreadsheet. It lumps them together. Over a long enough period you stop being able to tell which part you resent.

Two difficult employers in a row is usually enough to convince someone the whole profession is at fault. It is an entirely reasonable conclusion to draw from the evidence in front of them. It is also, quite often, wrong.

How to tell the difference

 
Signs it is
The environment
  • ✓You enjoy the job on the quiet days, when nobody is on your back
  • ✓What you dread is specific and has a name. A manager, a meeting, a Monday review
  • ✓You can identify a period in the same profession when you were genuinely happy
  • ✓You would accept the same job title elsewhere without hesitation
  • ✓You talk about behaviour rather than tasks when you describe the problem
Signs it is
The work itself
  • ✓Good weeks feel flat rather than satisfying. Nothing is wrong, but nothing lands
  • ✓A promotion or a meaningful rise made very little difference, or lasted a few weeks
  • ✓You have felt the same way at two or three employers with genuinely different cultures
  • ✓The parts of the week you look forward to sit outside your actual role
  • ✓You struggle to remember when the technical content last interested you

Environment problems tend to sound like this: nobody says thank you, I get blamed for things outside my control, I am expected to absorb work that keeps appearing, I have asked three times and nothing changes.

Work problems sound quieter, and they are easier to miss, because they do not come with an obvious villain. That last point is worth sitting with. Boredom is a legitimate reason to change direction. It is also a reason people feel strangely guilty about, particularly in a profession where the work is stable and well paid and the obvious response is to be grateful for it.

Get this wrong in either direction and you lose years.

A practical way to test it

 

If the questions above have not settled it, run a two-week energy audit. It is simple and it is more revealing than it sounds.

The two week energy audit
1

Keep a running list of every task you do, for a fortnight.

2

Score each one from minus five to plus five. Not on competence, and not on importance. Only on energy: did doing it leave you with more in the tank, or less?

3

Sort the list by score and look at where the negatives sit.

Clustered on tasks

It is the work.

Compliance, review, chasing records. Moving firms will not fix it.

Clustered on people

It is the place.

The catch-up, a particular partner, how feedback lands. The work is probably fine.

Most people can feel the answer coming by day four. The value of writing

Previous PostNext Post